Our Sponsor
Create work your clients can rely on
Your client doesn't care how their site was built. They care that it launches on time, runs on their own domain, and keeps working long after you hand it over.
With Lovable, you describe what your client needs and get a working version you can show them in the first meeting. Then you take it all the way to a live site on your client's domain, built to be found on Google. Lovable's project monitoring feature spots bugs and suggests fixes, so your name stays on work you're proud of.
Start today and take $5 off your first month.
Discount of $5 applies to first month of any paid plan. You need to sign up via this webpage in order to claim the discount. The discount applies to new and returning users without an active paid plan. Terms apply.
ONE WILD WORLD — NEWSLETTER
Fact-checked stories about the things you thought you knew.
Written for people who don't mind being corrected — or shocked.
ISSUE 069 · DEEP DIVE · MYTHS & MISINFORMATION
Bill Gates Called This Book Evil. Then America Pulled the Plug on Aid — and He Called That Killing.

Illustration: the debate over foreign aid, its costs and the lives it can save.
In 2009 a Zambian economist published a book arguing that foreign aid was keeping Africa poor. Bill Gates said books like hers were “promoting evil.” Sixteen years later, the United States cancelled most of its aid programmes in a matter of weeks — and Gates reached for even stronger words. So who was right? The awkward answer: both of them, about different kinds of aid.
“Promoting evil”
In May 2013, speaking at a televised forum in Australia, Bill Gates took aim at an economist named Dambisa Moyo. She “didn't know much about aid and what aid was doing,” he said, and her book was making rich countries less generous. “That's an evil thing,” he added, “and books like that – they're promoting evil.”
Moyo replied on her website. She called the remarks “inappropriate and disrespectful,” and pointed out that she had studied economics to doctoral level, worked as a consultant for the World Bank and grown up in Zambia — one of the countries the aid was supposed to help.
What the book actually said
Moyo was born in Lusaka in 1969, studied at Harvard and Oxford and spent eight years at Goldman Sachs. Her book, Dead Aid, came out in 2009. Its argument was blunt: more than a trillion dollars in aid had flowed to Africa over half a century, and much of it had made things worse.
Not all aid, though. Moyo said plainly that she was not attacking emergency relief after disasters, or charities working on the ground. Her target was the money one government hands to another. Aid like that, she argued, feeds corruption, props up bad leaders and — most damaging of all — lets governments ignore their own people. A government funded by its taxpayers has to listen to them. A government funded by donors only has to listen to donors. Her answer: phase it out within five to ten years, and replace it with trade, investment and borrowing on the bond markets.
Where she had a point
Aid often serves the giver as much as the receiver, and the United States offers a textbook example. For decades, American food aid had to be bought from American farmers, and much of it shipped on American-flagged vessels that charge more than the open market. A Cornell University study found that in 2006 alone, the shipping rule cost about $140 million more than competitive rates — about as much as USAID spent on non-emergency food aid in Africa. The economists Christopher Barrett and Daniel Maxwell estimated that it took more than two taxpayer dollars to deliver one dollar's worth of food.
And the biggest question of all — does aid make poor countries grow? — has never had a clean answer. In 2008 the economists Raghuram Rajan, later governor of India's central bank, and Arvind Subramanian combed through decades of data and found “little robust evidence of a positive (or negative) relationship” between aid and growth.
Where she got it wrong
Other researchers did find growth — just not much. A 2012 study led by Michael Clemens of the Center for Global Development found that increases in aid were followed, on average, by “modest increases in investment and growth,” with the effect shrinking the more aid a country received.
The book itself had problems. Clemens's colleague David Roodman found that it misdescribed Clemens's research, and that it claimed aid to Africa had been falling for twenty years when it had just hit record levels. His verdict: “sporadically footnoted, selective in its use of facts, sloppy, simplistic, illogical, and stunningly naive.”
And the case against aid is weakest exactly where the results are easiest to count: health. In 2003 President George W. Bush launched PEPFAR, a programme to treat and prevent HIV, mostly in Africa. The US government credits it with saving more than 25 million lives. The economist Jeffrey Sachs, one of Moyo's fiercest critics, summed up his objection in five words: “Aid did not kill Africa.”
2025: the plug gets pulled
On 20 January 2025, the new Trump administration froze foreign aid for 90 days. Within two weeks, Elon Musk, then leading the cost-cutting team known as DOGE, wrote that he had spent the weekend “feeding USAID into the wood chipper.” On 10 March, Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced that 83 per cent of USAID's programmes — some 5,200 contracts — had been cancelled. On 1 July, what was left was folded into the State Department.
The cuts were sold as a war on waste, and few voters knew how small the budget was. In a Kaiser Family Foundation survey, Americans guessed on average that foreign aid ate up 31 per cent of the federal budget. The real figure is about 1 per cent.
It was, in a sense, what Dead Aid had asked for — but not the way Moyo described it. She wanted government-to-government aid phased out over five to ten years. What happened took weeks, and hit HIV and malaria programmes along with everything else.
Gates did not stay quiet. On 8 May 2025, announcing that he would give away almost his entire fortune, he told The New York Times: “The world's richest man has been involved in the deaths of the world's poorest children.” He meant Musk.
How many deaths? Nobody knows yet. A study in The Lancet linked USAID-funded programmes to 91 million fewer deaths between 2001 and 2021, and projected more than 14 million extra deaths by 2030 if the cuts stand — over 4.5 million of them children under five. Those are models built on statistical associations, not counted deaths. Researchers at the Center for Global Development put the toll at roughly half a million to 1.6 million lives, and admitted that without direct data, “any estimates of lives lost remain guesswork.”
The honest version
Moyo was right that aid handed from one government to another has a weak record, and that aid often does as much for the donor as for the poor. Gates was right that some aid saves lives on a scale almost nothing else can match. The trouble is that “aid” is not one thing — and in 2025, America cut both kinds at once.
There is an odd echo between the two of them. Moyo wanted aid to come with an end date. Gates has now given his own foundation one: it closes on 31 December 2045. “People will say a lot of things about me when I die,” he wrote, “but I am determined that ‘he died rich’ will not be one of them.”
BY THE NUMBERS
$1 trillion+
aid to Africa over half a century, according to Dead Aid
31% vs 1%
Americans' average guess at foreign aid's share of the federal budget — and the real figure
$2 for $1
taxpayer cost of delivering one dollar's worth of American food aid, by one estimate
25 million+
lives the US government credits to PEPFAR since 2003
83%
USAID programmes cancelled by March 2025
$63.3 billion
US aid in 2024 — the most of any country, but only 0.22% of national income
2045
the year the Gates Foundation closes for good
Some aid saves millions of lives. Some mostly pays for the shipping. In 2025, America cut both.
SOURCES
Moyo, D., Dead Aid: Why Aid Is Not Working and How There Is a Better Way for Africa (2009).
Foreign Policy, “Feud watch: Dambisa Moyo responds to being called ‘evil’ by Bill Gates” (5 June 2013), citing The Sydney Morning Herald.
Bageant, E., Barrett, C. B. and Lentz, E., Cornell University study of US food aid shipping costs (2010), as reported by The New Humanitarian; Barrett, C. B. and Maxwell, D. G., Food Aid After Fifty Years (2005).
Rajan, R. G. and Subramanian, A., “Aid and Growth: What Does the Cross-Country Evidence Really Show?” Review of Economics and Statistics 90(4) (2008).
Clemens, M. A., Radelet, S., Bhavnani, R. R. and Bazzi, S., “Counting Chickens When They Hatch: Timing and the Effects of Aid on Growth,” The Economic Journal 122 (2012).
Roodman, D., Center for Global Development blog posts on Dead Aid (2009); Sachs, J., “Moyo's confused attack on aid for Africa,” VoxEU (2009).
US government figures on PEPFAR (2023–2025).
CBS News on Marco Rubio's announcement (10 March 2025); Bill Gates interview in The New York Times (8 May 2025), as reported by GeekWire; Gates Foundation announcement (8 May 2025), as reported by ABC News.
Cavalcanti, D. et al., The Lancet (2025); Kenny, C. and Sandefur, J., “Update on Lives Lost from USAID Cuts,” Center for Global Development (December 2025).
Kaiser Family Foundation survey (2015), as reported by PolitiFact; OECD preliminary data on official development assistance for 2024.
OneWildWorld!
Facts you never asked for. Knowledge you can't unsee.
Share this newsletter with someone who likes being corrected.
Missed the previous issue?
In Paris, Sally Hemings Could Have Walked Free. She Went Back to Slavery on One Condition — and Thomas Jefferson Kept It.
A little-known agreement that changed American history.
ONE MORE THING
You can read our MANY newsletters for free at our website:
Read our archive for free at OneWildWorld.com →
Privacy-first email. Built for real protection.
End-to-end encrypted, ad-free, and open-source. Proton Mail protects your inbox with zero data tracking.




